top of page
Search

Strategy Is Neither a Plan Nor an Objective: Why Clarity in Motion Defines the Best Companies

  • Writer: Dean Simmons
    Dean Simmons
  • Jul 15, 2023
  • 3 min read

Updated: Jun 1


ree

Introduction


In executive settings, few terms are as frequently overused as strategy. For many organizations, strategy has become a catchall: a synonym for goals, objectives, planning, or vision.


This confusion causes issues with decision making, capital allocation, and organizational momentum. When leaders conflate strategy with planning or objectives, they risk losing clarity, diluting focus, and undermining optimal execution. As a result, companies stall—not because their vision is flawed, but because their strategic foundation lacks focus and alignment.


At its core, strategy is not a list of initiatives. It is not a quarterly roadmap or an aspirational mission statement. That's why I say, strategy is clarity in motion. It is the discipline of knowing what matters most, aligning people and resources around it, and executing relentlessly until the job is done.


This article examines the most common misconceptions around strategy and proposes a more useful, operational definition—one grounded in focus, tradeoffs, and execution.


The Common Misconceptions


1. Strategy is not a plan

Planning and strategy are often mistakenly treated as interchangeable. While plans provide tactical structure, strategy is fundamentally about choice. It informs which plans are worth making—and which aren’t. As Michael E. Porter of Harvard Business School writes:


“Strategy is not a plan. It’s the creation of a unique and valuable position, involving a different set of activities.”


Plans are snapshots. They offer short-term sequencing. Strategy is dynamic because business is dynamic. It is the logic that shapes those plans, the filter that determines priorities, and the compass leaders turn to when conditions shift. Plans may guide execution. Strategy governs what is worth executing in the first place.


2. Strategy is not an objective

Objectives are destinations, measurable outcomes companies seek to achieve. But objectives are only as effective as the strategy behind them. Without strategic discipline, even the most ambitious targets become disconnected goals. Strategy ensures that objectives:

  • Reinforce one another rather than compete

  • Reflect the organization’s true differentiators

  • Are in directional alignment


In short, strategy makes objectives meaningful. It aligns the organizaion behind a unified approach.


3. Strategy is not vision

Vision is essential. It orients the company toward a future state worth pursuing. But vision without strategy is empty. It lacks the mechanism to get from here to there.


Where vision sets direction, strategy establishes the method and the margin of error. It demands tradeoffs, establishes boundaries, and defines what the company will not do in service of what matters most. Again, Porter is direct:


“The essence of strategy is choosing what not to do.”


Great strategy isn’t about doing more. It’s about doing less, but doing it more effectively.


What Strategy Actually Is

At its most functional, strategy is not a static document or slide deck—it’s a decision-making discipline or framework. It enables organizations to:

  • Prioritize high-impact actions over urgent noise

  • Allocate time, capital, and talent with purpose

  • React to change without losing direction


A strong strategic framework should be simple and feel practical. It should be something leaders reference weekly, not quarterly or annually. It should filter every initiative, guide every tradeoff, and frame every executive conversation.


Strategy puts clarity into action. It forces leadership teams to answer hard questions:

  • What are we really solving for?

  • Which customers are we choosing to serve—and which are we not?

  • What capabilities must we build to win?

  • What activities are distractions?


These are not philosophical debates. They are the clarity in strategic execution.


What Strategic Clarity Enables

When strategy is well-defined and well-communicated, the impact is immediate and tangible:

Organizational Element

Effect of Strategic Clarity

Leadership

Faster, more decisive choices

Teams

Alignment around fewer, more focused initiatives

Resource allocation

Capital and talent flow toward priorities, not politics

Execution

Less debate, more momentum

Culture

Shared understanding of purpose and progress

The result is not just better outcomes. It’s a fundamentally more unified organization—one that moves with intention and synergy rather than inertia or darting squirrels.


Conclusion

Strategy is not a plan. It is not an objective. It is not a document created during an expensive offsite and shelved for the rest of the year.


It is the active discipline of knowing what matters, rallying people around it, and staying the course long enough to see results.


Strategy is clarity in motion. Strategy isn’t just the static document it's written on. It’s a day-to-day operating mindset that shows up in every decision, every tradeoff, and every conversation.

 
 
 

Comments


©Copyright 2025 Blacksmith Harvester LLC

bottom of page